When designing embedded systems, choosing the right technology and tools can make a big difference in how well your project performs. The two most popular processing options are FPGAs (field-programmable gate arrays) and microcontrollers (MCUs). Each has powers for different functions, and choosing the right one is essential.
Apart from choosing a processor, you also need good PCB (Printed Circuit Board) design software. Popular options like KiCad, Eagle, and Altium Designer offer different features and prices. Some are open-source (free), while others require a license.
This guide explains the key differences between FPGAs and microcontrollers and compares KiCad, Eagle, and Altium to help you decide which tools best fit your project.
FPGAs Vs. Microcontrollers: Which is Right for You?
Both FPGAs and microcontrollers are used in embedded systems, but they work in different ways and are suitable for different types of projects.
What is FPGA?
FPGAs are specialized chips that can be programmed to perform various functions and reprogrammed as needed.
It is best for projects that require high-speed data processing or that handle multiple tasks simultaneously (parallel processing).
FPGAs are typically used in complex systems where flexibility and speed are essential, such as signal processing, data analysis, or image processing.
What are Microcontrollers?
Microcontrollers are simple, single-chip computers designed to control a specific function, such as controlling a sensor, motor, or display.
They are more cost-effective and energy-efficient than FPGAs.
Microcontrollers are best for straightforward tasks, such as controlling devices, reading sensor data, or managing small applications that don’t require a lot of speed.
Key differences between FPGA and microcontrollers
When deciding which one to use, consider these factors:
- Performance: FPGAs offer high-speed processing and handle multiple tasks simultaneously. On the other hand, microcontrollers are slow but good for tasks that do not require a lot of processing power.
- Flexibility: FPGA is more flexible as you can reprogram it for different tasks. Microcontrollers are less flexible but easier to use and set up.
- Cost: Microcontrollers are generally cheaper than FPGAs. For simple tasks, it is often the best choice. However, if you need flexibility and speed, FPGAs can be more expensive.
Comparison of PCB Design Software: KiCad, Eagle, and Altium
Once you’ve chosen a processor, you’ll need to design a circuit board to hold it. That’s where PCB design software like KiCad, Eagle, and Altium Designer comes in. Here’s how each one differs:
KiCad
- KiCad is open source, so it is free to download and use. This makes it popular among students, hobbyists, and even some professionals.
- It has all the essential features for designing PCBs, although it may lack some of the advanced tools that paid software offers.
- It is supported by a community of users who create and share improvements.
Eagle
- Eagle (owned by Autodesk) is user-friendly and strikes a balance between price and features. It has both free and paid versions, making it accessible to a variety of users.
- It is great for small to medium-sized projects with useful tools for library management and component design.
- With Eagle, you get more professional features than KiCad but without the high cost of some premium tools.
Altium Designer
- Altium Designer is a premium PCB design tool packed with advanced features. It is ideal for professionals working on complex projects.
- While it is more expensive, it includes many design options, from schematic capture to 3D modeling.
- Altium Designer is widely used in professional settings where high-quality and feature-rich design software is essential.
Feature Comparison: KiCad, Eagle and Altium
Here’s a quick look at what each software offers:
Ease of use:
- KiCad has a flexible, modular design but can take time to learn.
- Eagle is praised for its easy-to-use interface, which makes it suitable for beginners and advanced users alike.
- Altium Designer has more advanced tools, which are great but take time to master.
Libraries and Components:
- KiCad has an open library system where users often create and share parts.
- Eagle provides many libraries and makes it easy to integrate components.
- Altium Designer provides a large, high-quality component library that is often maintained by manufacturers.
Price:
- KiCad is free, making it a great choice for users on a budget.
- Eagle has both a free (limited) and inexpensive paid version, which is a good middle ground for hobbyists and small businesses.
- Altium Designer is more expensive and is for professionals who need a high-end tool for complex projects.
Choosing Between FPGAs and Microcontrollers for Your Project
Your comparison between FPGA vs Microcontrollers will depend on the needs of your project. Here’s an easy way to decide:
Choose an FPGA if your project requires high-speed, parallel processing, or flexibility. FPGAs are great for tasks that require fast data processing or changes over time.
Choose a microcontroller for simple applications where low cost and power efficiency are priorities. They are frequently used in consumer electronics, appliances, and basic automation systems.
Choosing between KiCad, Eagle, and Altium for PCB design
When it comes to PCB design software, here’s what each tool is best for:
- KiCad: Ideal for hobbyists, students, and those on a budget. It is free and contains the basic tools needed for PCB design.
- Eagle: Good balance of price and features. Eagle works well for small to medium-sized businesses or hobbyists who want a bit more functionality.
- Ultium Designer: Great for large or complex projects where advanced design tools are needed. It is the best choice for professionals who need complete control over every part of the PCB design process.
Conclusion
Choosing the right parts and design tools is the key to building the best-embedded systems. FPGAs are ideal for projects that require high speed and flexibility, while microcontrollers work well for simple, budget-friendly tasks. For PCB design, KiCad is the best free choice, Eagle offers a good balance of features, and Altium Designer is best for complex, professional projects.
If you need Embedded technology services, Discrete Circuits is the right choice. With high-quality designs and custom solutions, Discrete Circuits makes it easy to turn your ideas into reliable, well-designed systems, giving you expert support every step of the way.